Making Business Work for the Poor
December 12-14, 2004, San Francisco, CA
For three days in December, more than 1000 people from 60-plus countries converged in San Francisco to attend the World Resources Institute's 'Eradicating Poverty through Profit: Making Business Work for the Poor' conference. Representing a wide range of stakeholders from business, the private sector, and civil society, participants explored the relationship between business activity and economic development. Can companies, pursuing their core ‘business’ objectives deliver important ‘development’ benefits? Are low income communities ‘real’ markets? Plenaries and workshops examined how business is, today, interacting with poor people – as customers, as suppliers, and as partners in the cocreation of products and services.
The conference explored
private sector solutions to poverty with keynote addresses and other presentations,
panel discussions, sector or interest-specific workshops, and exhibits. See
below for summaries, videos and presentations from the sessions. For the list of attendees, click here [1]. For the complete
program check here [2].
Conference Summary
A comprehensive 16-page
summary of the conference can be found here [3].
A full 45-page conference summary, which includes the summaries of each of the
9 Track Sessions, can be found here [4].
Plenary Sessions
Framing the
Issues for Practical Corporate Engagement: Myths, Realities, and Necessary Strategies
C.K.
Prahalad, Harvey C. Fruehauf Professor of Business Administration
& Professor of Corporate Strategy and International Business, Stephen M.
Ross School of Business, University of Michigan and Chief Executive Officer,
The Next Practice
Video [5]
A Perspective
from the IT Sector
Carly
Fiorina, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Hewlett-Packard
Video [6]
Building a Foundation
at the Bottom of the Pyramid: Access Innovation and Growth
Christopher
Rodrigues, President and Chief Executive Officer, Visa International
Video [7] /
Powerpoint [8]
Values-Based
Guidelines: Building the Case for “BOP Principles”
James
A. Harmon, Chairman of World Resources Institute, former Chairman
of Export-Import Bank of the US
Video [9]
A Perspective
from the Telecommunications Sector
Arun
Sarin, Chief Executive Officer, Vodafone
Charlotte Grezo, Director of Corporate Social
Responsibility, Vodafone
Video [10]
A Perspective
from the Agricultural Sector
J.
Erik Fyrwald, Group Vice President, DuPont Agriculture & Nutrition
Video [11] / Powerpoint [12]
Committing to
the BOP: How we made the decision and how we implemented it
C.
K. Prahalad, Harvey C. Fruehauf Professor of Business Administration
& Professor of Corporate Strategy and International Business, Stephen M.
Ross School of Business, University of Michigan and Chief Executive Officer,
The Next Practice
Yogesh C. Deveshwar, Chairman, ITC, Ltd.
Nachiket Mor, Ph.D. , Executive Director,
Corporate Banking, ICICI Bank Ltd.
Video [13]
Toward a Base
of the Pyramid Protocol
Stuart
Hart, S.C. Johnson Chair of Sustainable Global Enterprise and Professor
of Management, Johnson School of Management, Cornell University - PPT
Scott Johnson, Vice President- Global Environmental
& Safety Actions, S.C. Johnson & Son, Inc.
Video [14] / Powerpoint [15]
Petroleum, Profits
and Poverty – A Changing Philosophy of Community Engagement
Peter
J. Robertson, Vice Chairman of the Board, ChevronTexaco
Video [16]
Governments
as Enablers of Private Sector Solutions
Alan
Larson, Under Secretary of State for Economic, Business and Agricultural
Affairs, U.S. Department of State
Mark Malloch Brown, Administrator, United
Nations Development Programme
His Excellency Dipak Patel, Minister of Commerce,
Trade and Industry, Republic of Zambia
Video [17]
Whither Technology?
Probing the Bleeding Edge of Technology and its Applications in the Service
of Business Engagement with Low-Income Consumers
Craig
Mundie, Senior Vice President and Chief Technical Officer of Advanced
Strategies and Policy, Microsoft
Video [18] / Powerpoint [19]
The Private
Sector as the Enabler for the Public Sector Agenda
Herman
Mulder, Senior Executive Vice President and Co-Head of Group Risk
Management, ABN AMRO
Video [20] / Powerpoint [21]
Financial Models
for Success
Robert
Annibale, Global Director, Citigroup's Microfinance Group
Eduardo Bazoberry, General Manager, Prodem
Private Financing Fund S.A.
Elizabeth Littlefield, Director, Chief Executive
Officer, Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (CGAP), World Bank
Jacqueline Novogratz, Chief Executive Officer,
Acumen Fund
Matthew Gamser, Director, Organizational
Learning, Development Alternatives, Inc.
Video [22]
Business Models
for Success
Allen
Hammond, Vice President for Special Projects and Innovation, World
Resources Institute
Louis C. Boorstin, Manager, Grassroots Business
Organizations, International Finance Corporation
Paul Meyer, Chief Executive Officer, Voxiva
Richard Sandbrook, Independent Senior Advisor,
United Nations Development Programme
Holly
Wise, Director, Global Development Alliance, U.S. Agency for International
Development (USAID)
Video [23]
Track Sessions
Track 1 - Getting Started
in Doing Business with the Poor: Learning Journeys of Leading Companies from
the World Business Council for Sustainable Development’s Sustainable Livelihoods
Project - Summary
(PDF) [24]
Session 1:
Experiences of national and multinational corporations from around the globe
Cameron
Rennie, Director, Sustainable Livlihoods, World Business Council
for Sustainable Development
Faye Yoshihara, S.C. Johnson
Scott Johnson, Vice President, Global Environmental
& Safety Actions, S.C. Johnson
Cecile Churet, Program Officer, Sustainable
Livlihoods, World Business Council for Sustainable Development
Session 2: Experiences from World Business Council for
Sustainable Development Regional Network Members
Martin
Eweg, Principal Agricultural Extension Specialist, South African
Sugarcane Research Institute
Sharat Dhall, Unilever
Session 3:
Gearing Up - Tools to assist managers in designing their own SL business models;
guidance in thinking about appropriate financing strategies, collaboration with
development organizations and on working in cluster with other companies to
harness synergies and maximize benefits to the communities.
Fanny
Calder, Associate Fellow, Chatham House
Anders Nordstrom, Senior Project Manager,
ABB
Barbara Dubach, Vice President, Sustainable
Development Coordination, Holcim
Rakesh Khanna, Development Alternatives,
Inc.
Track 2 - Financial
Services - Summary (PDF) [25]
Session 1a: From rags to cashmere: The BOP success of Khan
Bank Mongolia
Matthew Gamser,
Director, Organizational Learning, Development Alternatives Inc.
J. Peter
Morrow, Chief Executive
Officer, Khan Bank
Sukhbold
Sandag, Branch Executive,
Khan Bank – Powerpoint [26]
Session 1b:
Achieving breakthroughs in the scale of microfinance: Emerging lessons from
an HP-led pilot in Uganda
Janine Firpo,
Director, Global Multisector Initiatives, Hewlett-Packard – Powerpoint1 [27]
/ Powerpoint2 [28]
James Dailey,
Technical Project Manager, Grameen Technology Center - Powerpoint [29]
Roy Jacobowitz,
Vice President, Accion International
Beth Porter,
Vice President, Technical Operations, Freedom from Hunger - Powerpoint [30]
Session 2a:
South Africa's Financial Sector Charter: How the private sector is organizing
to bank the unbanked
Gerhard Coetzee,
Director, Development Finance, ECIAfrica Pty Ltd - Powerpoint [31]
Jonathan
Dixon, Chief Director,
Financial Sector Policy, National Treasury, South Africa
Lincoln Mali,
Director, Convenience Banking, Standard Bank - Powerpoint [32]
Bheka M Manana,
General Manager, Africa & Emerging Market – FBS, ABSA Bank
David Porteous,
Managing Director, Recap International LLC
Session
2b: Migrants & Remittances: Products and business opportunities
in host and sending countries
Cerstin
Sander, Principal Consultant,
Bannock Consulting Ltd.
Robert Annibale,
Global Director, Citigroup's Microfinance Group - Powerpoint [33]
Nachiket
Mor, Ph.D., Executive Director,
Corporate Banking, ICICI Bank Ltd. – Powerpoint1 [34]
/ Powerpoint2 [35]
Session 3a:
India's banks & microfinance: Public and private financial institutions
joining up to reach rural customers
Sukhwinder
Arora, Financial Sector
Development Advisor, Department for International Development UK
N. Balasubramanian,
Deputy Managing Director, Small Industries Development Bank of India - Powerpoint [36]
Geoff Davis,
Chief Executive Officer, UNITUS
Nachiket
Mor, Ph.D., Executive Director,
Corporate Banking, ICICI Bank Ltd. - Powerpoint1 [37]
/ Powerpoint2 [38]
Moumita Sen
Sarma, Vice President,
Head - Microfinance, India, ABN AMRO Bank - Powerpoint [39]
Session
3b: Credit bureau development in Latin America: New financial services
for the poor
Robin
Young, Senior Development
Specialist, Development Alternatives, Inc.
Monica Hernandéz
de Phillips, Executive
Vice President, Banco Solidario - Powerpoint [40]
Luis Armando
Montenegro Monterrosa,
Superintendent of the Financial System, El Salvador - Powerpoint [41]
Rodolfo O.
Ploder, Group Executive,
Equifax Latin America - Powerpoint [42]
Track 3 – Connectivity
- Summary (PDF) [43]
Session 1:
Innovative business and service models with cellular platforms
Allen Hammond,
Vice President for Special Projects and Innovation, World Resources Institute
Peter Bladin,
Director, Grameen Technology Center
Nobuhle Chonco,
Senior Manager, Vodacom Community Services – Powerpoint [44]
Ramon Isberto,
Head, Public Affairs, Smart Communications, Inc.
Charlotte
Grezo, Director of Corporate
Social Responsibility, Vodafone
Session 2:
Innovative business and service models with IT platforms
Allen Hammond,
Vice President for Innovation and Special Projects, World Resources Institute
Deepak Amin,
Co-founder and Chief Executive Officer, Covelix, Inc.
Amir Alexander
Hasson, President, United
Villages, Inc; Co-Founder, First Mile Solutions, LLC - Powerpoint [45]
Keith Kegley,
Director, Emerging Markets Services, Microsoft MSN Division
John Sherry,
Anthropologist, People and Practices Research, Intel Corporation
Dan Shine,
AMD
Session 3:
Innovative business and service models with an off-grid platform, including
handhelds, POS terminals, stand-alone kiosks, smart cards
Allen Hammond,
Vice President for Innovation and Special Projects, World Resources Institute
Deborah Arnold,
Vice President, Product and Market Integration, VISA - Powerpoint [46]
Eduardo Bazoberry,
General Manager, Prodem Private Financing Fund SA – Powerpoint1 [47]
/ Powerpoint2 [48]
Anand Tawker,
General Manager, e-inclusion and Emerging Market Solutions, Hewlett-Packard
Track 4 – Energy
for Economic Vitality - Summary
(PDF) [49]
Session 1:
Success Stories
David Jhirad,
Ph.D., Vice President for Science & Research, World Resources Institute
- Powerpoint [50]
Christine
Eibs-Singer, Chief Operating
Officer and Deputy Executive Director, E+Co - Powerpoint [51]
Damian Miller,
Director Rural Operations, Shell Solar - Powerpoint [52]
Fabio Luis
de Oliviera Rosa, President,
Institute for Development of Natural Energy and Sustainability (IDEAAS)
Robert Freling,
Executive Director, Solar Electric Light Fund (SELF)
Session 2:
Scaling Out
David Jhirad,
Ph.D., Vice President for Science & Research, World Resources Institute
- Powerpoint [53]
Sarah Adams,
Manager, Access Programme, Electricite de France - Powerpoint [54]
Hari Sharan,
Ph.D., Co-Chairman, DESI Power - Powerpoint and Final Paper (PDF) [55]
Session 3:
Scaling Up
David Jhirad,
Ph.D., Vice President for Science & Research, World Resources Institute
- Powerpoint [56]
Louis C.
Boorstin, Manager, Grassroots
Business Organizations, International Finance Corporation - Powerpoint [57]
Christopher
O'Brien, Vice President,
Strategy and Government Relations, Sharp Solar Systems Division - Powerpoint [58]
Bruce Kahn,
Smith Barney Citigroup
Damian Miller,
Director Rural Operations, Shell Solar - Powerpoint [59]
Track 5 – Consumer
Products - Summary (PDF) [60]
Session 1: What is known about markets at the Bottom of the Pyramid? What are the business model implications?
William Kramer,
Senior Fellow, World Resources Institute
Guillermo
d’Andrea, Professor
of Business Administration, IAE – School of Business, Universidad Austral
- Powerpoint [61]
Sean Gallagher,
Research Analyst, World Resources Institute - Powerpoint [62]
Ricardo Neves,
Author, Marketing and Strategy Consultant - PDF [63]
Alejandro
Stengel, Senior Director,
Booz Allen Hamilton - Powerpoint [64]
Faye Yoshihara,
Pontes Consulting
Session 2:
Listening to the Bottom of the Pyramid
Valeria Budinich,
Vice President, Full Economic Citizenship Initiative, Ashoka
Inez Murray,
Market Research Director, Women’s World Banking - PDF [65]
Xavier Guy
Richard, Director of Companies,
Amazon Caribbean Guyana
Darrel Rhea,
Chief Executive Officer, Cheskin
David Green,
Founder, Project Impact/ARAVIND
Fabio Rosa,
Founder, Institute for Development of Natural Energy and Sustainability
Track 6 – Partnering
Strategies - Summary (PDF) [66]
Session 1: Deconstructing partnerships: case analyses of extractive industries in Africa
Richard Sandbrook,
Independent Senior Advisor, United Nations Development Programme
Anders Henning
Nordstrom, Senior Project
Manager, ABB - Powerpoint [67]
Simon Lowes,
Manager of Community Engagement, International Relations, ChevronTexaco - Powerpoint [68]
Kristi Ragan,
Director, Global Business Solutions, Development Alternatives, Inc.
Session 2a:
Reconstructing partnerships: Experiences in Latin America
Matt Jeschke,
Manager, CSR Services, Business for Social Responsibility
Barbara
Dubach, Vice President,
Sustainable Development Coordination, Holcim
Andreas Eggenberg,
AMANCO Guatemala
Clotilde
Fonseca, Fundacion Omar
Dengo - Powerpoint [69]
Kate McKee,
Director, Microenterprise Division, U.S. Agency for International Development
Session 2b:
Economic diversity through partnerships: BP and SBP’s Psi Tanzania
Jennifer
Barsky, SustainAbility
Merrick Dunster,
Regional Social Investment Manager BP Southern Africa (Pty) Ltd
Corin Mitchell,
Director, Operations, SBP
Session 3a:
Making partnerships work in the 21st century
Jane Nelson,
Senior Fellow, Director, Corporate Social Responsibility Initiative, Kennedy
School of Government, Harvard University, and Director, Business Leadership
and Strategy, Prince of Wales International Business Leaders Forum
Joi Corrado,
Corporate Social Responsibility, American Water
Martin Fisher,
Approtec
Jesse Moore,
Director, Private Sector Development, CARE Canada
Pamela Passman,
Vice President, Global Corporate Affairs, Microsoft
Session 3b:
Microfinance & Partnerships
Bob Fitch,
Managing Director, Enterplan Limited
Arturo Condo,
Associate Dean, Central American Institute of Business Administration (INCAE)
Robert Davis,
Senior Vice President, Program Services, Freedom from Hunger
Janine Firpo,
Director, Global Multisector Initiatives, Hewlett-Packard
Nick Hughes,
Head of Social Products and Enterprise, Vodafone Group Services Ltd
Track 7 – The Policy Dimension - Summary (PDF) [70]
Session 1: Eliminating red tape through public-private partnership engagement
Benjamin
Herzberg, Investment Climate
Unit, World Bank - Powerpoint [71]
Natwar Gotecha,
Chief Executive Officer, Founding Member, Tanzanian Investor Council - Powerpoint [72]
Amela Malicbegovic,
Head, Association of Central Bosnia Entrepreneurs - Powerpoint [73]
Session 2:
Developing mortgage markets
Steven Bernstein,
Senior Advisor, U.S. Treasury Department and Director, White House Initiative
on African Mortgage Markets
Sally Merrill,
Senior Associate, The Urban Institute - Powerpoint [74]
Alex Pollock,
Fellow, American Enterprise Institute
Phillip Thigpen,
President, 1789 Capital Advisors
Session 3:
Improving the business climate
E. Anthony
Wayne, Assistant Secretary
of State for Economic and Business Affairs, U.S. Department of State
His Excellency
Dionisio Borda, Minister
of Finance, Republic of Paraguay
George Manu,
Chief Executive Offiver, Creative Squares Ltd
His Excellency
Alwi Shihab, Welfare Minister,
Republic of Indonesia
Axel Peuker,
Manager of the Investment Climate Unit, Private Sector Development Vice Presidency,
World Bank
Track 8 – Asset-Building among the Poor: Effective Strategies in the US and Developing World Markets - Summary (PDF) [75]
Session 1:
Market-based approaches to eradicating poverty: New roles for NGOs
John Weiser,
Principal, Brody Weiser Burns Consultants
Terri Feeley,
Executive Director, SFWorks
Michele Kahane,
Former Program Officer, Ford Foundation; Director, Special Projects, Center
for Corporate Citizenship at Boston College
Paul Rice,
Chief Executive Officer, TransFair USA
Session 2:
Breaking out of silos: Sharing best practices across national boundaries, economic
sectors, and institutional boundaries
Eliot Jamison,
Partner, Origo Inc.
Jeremy Hockenstein,
Digital Divide Data
Mona Masri,
Citibank
Mauricio
Medina Gala, Citibank
Branca Minic,
Director, Workforce Development, Manpower
Carlos Nomoto,
Vice President for Educational & Sustainable Development, ABN AMRO Brazil
Track 9 – Capital Investment - Summary (PDF) [76]
Session 1: Financial intermediaries: A key to successful deployment of capital in emerging markets
Amber Nystrom,
Social Fusion
Paul Fletcher,
Actis
Peter Johnson,
Partner, Developing World Markets
Bob Patillo,
Founder, Gray Ghost Capital
Jan Piercy,
Advisor, ShoreBank Corporation
Session 2:
Harnessing synergies: social and environmental interventions and the bottom
line
Robert Rubinstein,
Brooklyn Bridge/Triple Bottom Line Investment Conference
Noah Beckwith,
Aureos Advisors - Powerpoint [77]
T. David
Hodgkinson, Special Advisor,
ASEAN China Investment Fund
Sara Olsen,
Founding Partner, SVT Consulting - Powerpoint [78]
Other Sessions
Session 1: MNC business laboratory: Two global companies explore low-income markets - Summary [79]
Stuart Hart,
S.C. Johnson Chair of Sustainable Global Enterprise and Professor of
Management, Johnson School of Management, Cornell University
George D. Carpenter, Director of Corporate Sustainable Development, Proctor & Gamble
Ted London, Director, Base of the Pyramid Learning Laboratory, Adjunct Assistant Professor, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Paul V. Tebo, Former Corporate Vice President, Safety, Health, and Environment, DuPont
Session 2: Social Entrepreneurship, the BOP, and Economic Development - Summary [80]
Valeria Budinich, Vice President, Full Economic Citizenship Initiative, Ashoka
Mercedes Canalda de Beras-Goico, Executive Director, Dominican Association for the Development of Women (ADOPEM) - Powerpoint [81]
Arturo Garcia, Founder, Red de Agricultores Sustentables y Autogestivos (RASA)
David Green, Founder, Project Impact/ARAVIND - PDF [82]
Fabio Rosa,
Founder, Institute for Development of Natural Energy and Sustainability - PDF [83]
Session 3: Poverty, Profits, and Pushing Water Uphill: A Reality Check for Business and NGOs - Summary [84]
Kurt Hoffman, Director, Shell Foundation
Sachin Kapila, Group Biodiversity Advisor, Shell Foundation
Damian Miller, Director of Rural Operations, Shell