Following Remittances Around the World

Submitted by Courtland Walker on December 9, 2005 - 16:09.
With international remittance flows to the developing world set to top $167bn this year, a newly released report by the United Nations shows that remittance flows to the African continent, averaging US$17bn per annum between 2000 and 2003, have surpassed Foreign Direct Investment during the same period.

While official aid remains atop the list of external finance flows to Africa, worldwide remittance flows are more than double official aid, and governments, NGOs and the private sector alike are beginning to capitalize on these transfers as a driving force for growth.


Case in point, the Latin American Federation of banks recently announced a plan to channel remittances into small business loans and a range of other financial products to benefit the poor in Latin American and Caribbean countries.


Meanwhile across the Pacific, non-profits like Unlad Kabayan are funneling remittance payments from migrant workers into sustainable micro-enterprise creation.


Step further to the west and you can find emerging private sector enterprises like Thamel.com, providing an innovative e-commerce platform as a vehicle for remittance payments by the Nepalese diaspora.  And with the proliferation of mobile phones across the world, providers from the Philippines to South Africa have turned their attention to the facilitation of remittance transfers.


Speaking on remittances, Dilip Ratha, co-author of the World Bank's 2006 World Economic Prospects Report, notes:


"High fees are a significant drain on the savings of the migrants and also a significant drain on the funds that are flowing to essentially poor people."


“Reducing remittance costs can increase migrants’ savings and result in increased flows to developing countries – to poor people.”


With the increasing formalization of the once largely informal remittances market (still estimated to be as large as 50% of the formal market), improved systems and technology, such as those mentioned above, are emerging to facilitate faster, simpler transfers; simultaneously, and most importantly, driving down fees.


That these improvements in the remittances market, directly benefitting the poor, are emerging sustainably and often times profitably from the private, NGO, and government sectors alike, attest once more to the opportunities for poverty alleviation and income generation, lying in wait at the bottom of the pyramid.

Photo Source


. . . . .
Submitted by _Alex Bloom on December 9, 2005 - 19:11.
Also relevant: in September, the UN Commission on International Migration issued a Report recommending the creation of an "Inter-Agency Global Migration Facility" in response to the growth of global migration (in the last 20 years, the number has doubled from 100 to 200 million).

What's interesting is that the report mentions the controversy surrounding remittances: should they be taxed as income? The UN report says no, but economics Prof. Bhagwati argues yes (in Oct. 6 Financial Times, "A Deeply Flawed Report on Global Migration"), particularly since the income of migrants is often higher than that of domestic workers. My opinion? I think that 1. remittances are theoretically taxable income for the recipients, however 2.the transfer of remittances to developing countries should be encouraged, not taxed BUT 3. they shouldn't be taxable anyway until recipients rise above the poverty line.
Submitted by _arcangelgbrl on December 11, 2005 - 22:48.
OFW dollars fail to spur Philippine economy (OFW is the acronym for Overseas Filipino Worker) This is an interesting article that talks about issues that are seldom discussed in the remittances discourse. A lot of experts are hyping the potential effects of increasing remittance flows on reducing poverty...the article makes the case that an increase in remittance flows does not necessarily translate into wide spread benefits. Don't get me wrong, I strongly believe that remittances have the potential to significantly reduce poverty in the developing world but economic reform is just as important. It's common, for example, in the Philipines to see family members sit around and wait for money to come from Saudi Arabia, Hong Kong, or Singapore. The money they receive provides a disincentive for many to find work. In this sense, remittances act as a form of welfare. I believe that the issues raised in the OFW article are overlooked in the remittances debate, which give people the wrong idea that remittances are a kind of panacea for poverty allevation. M. Gabriel Unlad Kabayan Migrant Services Foundation, Inc.
Submitted by _Alex Bloom on December 12, 2005 - 12:21.
Interesting charts that show the huge unmet demand for remittance services in China and South Africa. "In China alone, the potential market for domestic money transfers—from the country’s major industrial centers to poorer rural areas—could top $30 billion a year." The problem is that transferring money rural residents is difficult and therefore expensive: "To transfer $45 from South Africa to a neighboring country can cost as much as 10 percent using informal hand delivery, most often by taxi drivers on regular cross-border routes. And an inter-bank wire transfer can cost more than 55 percent in the region."

Meanwhile, Haiti has enabled better delivery of remittances.
Submitted by _arcangelgbrl on December 16, 2005 - 23:15.
Below is a link to another article which talks about more issues that are seldom discussed in the recent press on remittances. I'm not trying to be a pessimist...I just think that the human context is largely missing in a lot of the press that is generated regarding remittances. http://www.iht.com/articles/2005/12/16/news/phils.php
Submitted by Henry on May 14, 2006 - 22:44.

Dear Nextbillion and readers,

Radio Open Source (radioopensource.org) will be doing a show on migrant remittances this Thursday. It would be great to get your feedback on people we should talk to, articles we should read, or anything that you think might contribute to the show.Most importantly, we are trying to bring people to our blog who can share their experiences with us. We are especially interested to hear from people who participate in remittances (both sending and receiving), but we are eager to talk to non-profit workers, employers, and any blogger who has something to add.Open Source is a public radio show that uses the Internet as its primary research source and community. The link to our Remittances show-in-progress post is: http://www.radioopensource.org/harnessing-remittances/

Thanks very much, and we hope to hear from you on our blog,

Henry Shepherd
Radio Open Source


Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Basic HTML tags are accepted.
  • To ensure that you are human, your comment must first be previewed, then posted to the site. Please click "Preview" to see how your comment will look when posted.