New Cellphone-based Money Transfer Service is Introduced

Submitted by Francisco Noguera on April 2, 2008 - 14:58.
April 01, 2008 - 14:00, The Wall Street Journal
Wiring Money Turns Wireless in New Plan

Western Union Co., hoping to boost its share of the money-transfer market, is teaming up with RadioShack Corp. and a small wireless company to offer a service that lets people send money through their cellphones.

The service is aimed at immigrants to the U.S. who regularly send money to family members in their native countries. Many of these immigrants don't have bank accounts and send the money by taking cash to a transfer service such as Western Union or a host of other firms.

Western Union, which already has a big share of the $300 billion global money-transfer market, hopes the cellphone service will bring in new clients and encourage existing customers to use it for a broader range of money transfers -- such as paying utility bills and sending money domestically. People without bank accounts now pay these bills in a variety of ways, including at convenience stores.

Wireless companies have long sought ways for customers to use cellphones to manage bank accounts or as virtual wallets in place of credit cards. While these applications are popular in Asia and parts of Europe, they have gained little acceptance in the U.S., where tech-savvy consumers already check bank accounts online and see little advantage to using cellphones instead of credit cards.

Past money-transfer efforts using prepaid cards, ATM networks and computers "never had traction in the remittance space, since the technologies in the developed world [from] where the money was sent weren't equally represented in the developing world where the money was received," said Matt Dill, general manager of Western Union Mobile. "The true value of mobile banking may be realized in places where the cellphone is the dominant consumer technology."

RadioShack and Western Union are offering the service in conjunction with Trumpet Mobile, a small wireless provider whose parent, Dallas-based Affinity Mobile LLC, developed the secure financial platform used in the service. Trumpet hopes to use the service to sign up more phone customers.

To use the service, people go to one of RadioShack's more than 4,000 stores and sign up for a Trumpet prepaid phone, which is required under the program. Customers can then load up to $200 onto their phones for cash transfer via Western Union's network either within the U.S. or internationally.

RadioShack hopes the service will help it beef up wireless sales. Many of the chain's stores already handle payments for Sprint Nextel bills and RadioShack's own credit cards. The Fort Worth, Texas-based company will use its retail staff to promote the program.

"People do not know much about moving money on a mobile phone. It's been a ground-up education for our sales force and will be for our customers," said Bob Kilinski, senior vice president of wireless marketing for RadioShack.

Continue reading

Submitted by Bal K Joshi on April 8, 2008 - 22:05.
I think when a technology redefines a traditional value chain offering new unique value proposition then the adoption of the technology is inevitable. I feel like saying it’s a value proposition stupid! The adoption is defined by what unique social and economic value it can deliver. As these type of technologies comes available not only to large players like Western Union but also directly to banks and micro finance institutions in remittance driven economies, we will begin to see interesting outputs at the end of the value chain. Who knows one day, a diaspora would want to pay monthly EMI through a cell phone for a yak farm in the Himalayas of Nepal for his wife or his brother financed by local micro finance. For 300+ billion remittance market to re-invent itself the technology has to be driven from the recipient country. The product development process has to come from home country side. Question I would like to leave with is. Shall western union start partnering with banks and micro finance institutions around the world as a remittance service provider or remittance service facilitator? The world of Cross Border ACH which is still in its infancy is already given stiff competition for Western Union like companies. As new technologies emerge, new business models emerge. It will be very interesting to see how cell-phones will redefine the remittances industry.
Submitted by Al Hammond on April 9, 2008 - 17:23.
Bal Joshi’s comment is important. As one of the innovators of novel remittance systems that has come bottom-up (in Nepal), his work is an important demonstration that novel approaches don’t depend on large, multinational companies. But I don’t think that technology adoption is inevitable—consumer habits are hard to change, and remittance is in fact a consumer service. To me, change in this market is inevitable, but driven by competition. Rates have come down sharply in Latin America for that reason, but have not come down (from the 17% that Western Union typically charges for a remittance transfer) in Africa and Asia—except where novel approaches or mobile phone-based systems have begun to penetrate, such as in the Philippines. So I think we won’t know until the market decides, and it’s interesting that Western Union is feeling enough competition that it has decided to innovate too. If I had to bet, it would be that the winning solution would be more easily accessible than the Western Union entry, and that we will see a lot more innovation in this space before we get there.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Basic HTML tags are accepted.
  • To ensure that you are human, your comment must first be previewed, then posted to the site. Please click "Preview" to see how your comment will look when posted.